I-9 software GryphonHR

DOJ Reduces I-9 Related Fines for New Mexico Company


Sep 15, 2023 

Share this article:

DOJ Reduces I-9 Related Fines for New Mexico Company

Recent developments in the case of Kodiak Oilfield Services LLC, a small New Mexico-based company, shed light on the critical importance of I-9 compliance for employers. The Department of Justice component overseeing immigration matters has reduced the fine Kodiak must pay for alleged failure to prepare or submit employment eligibility forms, emphasizing the gravity of such violations.


Understanding the Kodiak Case:


Size Matters:
Kodiak, employing fewer than 100 individuals, is classified as a small business. This distinction played a role in the reduction of fines, underlining the considerations for small enterprises in cases of I-9 noncompliance.


Lack of Bad Faith:
The judge determined that Kodiak's violations were not in bad faith, highlighting the need for comprehensive knowledge and evidence in assessing employer conduct before investigations.


Seriousness of Violations:
Failure to submit I-9 forms is considered among the most serious violations, as it undermines the purpose of employment verification requirements. This acknowledgment serves as a reminder of the importance of thorough I-9 compliance.


Default Judgment
: Kodiak did not respond to the complaint lodged by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, resulting in a default judgment on liability. This highlights the necessity for prompt and proper responses to legal matters.


Why Employers Should Consider Electronic I-9 Solutions:


The Kodiak case underscores the critical need for efficient and foolproof I-9 compliance procedures. An electronic I-9 solution, such as GryphonHR, can offer several benefits:


Streamlined Documentation:
Electronic solutions facilitate the accurate preparation, submission, and storage of I-9 forms, reducing the risk of paperwork violations.


Timely Notifications:
Employers receive timely reminders and notifications for key compliance deadlines, ensuring that forms are completed within the required timeframes.


Efficient Accuracy:
An electronic I-9 compliance solution can help to prevent errors or omissions and provide a streamlined process for completing and managing the Form I-9, minimizing the risk of ongoing violations.


Secure Data Storage:
With redundant infrastructure and secure data centers, electronic solutions like GryphonHR ensure that sensitive employee information is protected.


Accessibility Anywhere:
Employers can access I-9 information from any location, enabling seamless compliance management regardless of external challenges.



The Kodiak case serves as a stark reminder of the legal ramifications employers face in cases of I-9 noncompliance. By leveraging electronic I-9 solutions like GryphonHR, employers can proactively safeguard against potential violations, streamline compliance processes, and ensure the secure storage of critical employee data. With comprehensive electronic solutions in place, businesses can navigate I-9 compliance with confidence and peace of mind.


Contact GryphonHR
to learn more about the benefits of a compliant Form I-9 solution.


Share this article:

GryphonHR icon

Authored By: GryphonHR Blog Contributor


GryphonHR blog contributors include , consultants, researchers, and other subject-matter experts who’ve written content for our blog.

Sign-up for our Form I-9 Newsletter

Stay updated on Form I-9 and E-Verify!

News Side Bar


Interactive Guide

a woman is sitting at a desk in front of a laptop computer .

Is your I-9 compliance software placing you at risk? Learn more about the compliance requirements for electronic I-9 systems and how to evaluate important features. Skip the form and download this interactive guide!

Download the Guide

Complimentary E-Book

an e-book about preventing discrimination during the 1-9 process

Avoiding discrimination during the Form I-9 process is critical to preventing liability, hefty fines, and unfair hiring practices. Download our free e-book to learn more.

Get It Now

Recent Blog Articles

A woman is holding a cell phone with a picture of remote I-9 verification.
By GryphonHR 12 Apr, 2024
Navigate remote I-9 verifications and get expert insights, best practices and more in this guide.
I9 verification documents and justice concept
By GryphonHR 04 Apr, 2024
Explore how the DOJ's focus on enforcing non-discrimination in Form I-9 verification impacts employers. This article provides a deep dive into a recent case, outlining essential compliance practices, resources, and insights to avoid penalties.
electronic I-9 concept
By GryphonHR 29 Mar, 2024
Explore essential factors for electronic I-9 systems, gaining key insights into I-9 compliance within this detailed guide.
Share by: